Emily Henry has finally broken her silence on the Beach Read film post-Gus Everett casting. But do her words really tell us anything?

Do you ever have those moments where you think too hard about something and when it happens you feel like you willed it into being?

I had one of those moments Tuesday afternoon, when I opened Instagram to upload a photo to accompany this blog post and saw a clip of Emily Henry on TODAY with Jenna & Sheinelle breaking her silence on the Beach Read adaptation post-Patrick Schwarzenegger casting. And so my original planned post, on her monthlong silence, went out the window — sort of.

Henry gave her first public comments on the project in over a month Tuesday morning, during an appearance that included promotion for the new paperback version of Great Big Beautiful Life, and a few summer reading picks, including Kennedy Ryan’s newest, Score. And while she technically talked about the Beach Read film, she ultimately said very little — and nothing explicitly about Schwarzenegger or her feelings about his casting as the film’s male lead, Augustus “Gus” Everett.

Schwarzenegger was announced as Gus in mid-April. Fans vocally questioned the casting, with complaints including that Schwarzenegger doesn’t have the physical look of the character and his nepo-baby background is at odds with Gus’s own. Comments on screenwriter and director Yulin Kuang’s Instagram casting announcement were soon limited, as users filled the comment section with disbelieving remarks and demands she recast the role. 

Henry’s silence on the casting immediately drew fan and media attention.

Co-host Jenna Bush Hager asked Henry how she communicates that “this is going to be fine, guys” to fans when they’re not all excited by the direction of the project. Neither Henry or Bush Hager specifically referenced Schwarzenegger or the fan ire directed at him during the exchange, and Henry kept her response brief and general. 

“I also have to sit back and, like, let it unfold. It’s not – I mean, it is our baby, the readers’ and my baby, but it’s also the filmmakers’ baby and the studio’s baby and I’m along for the ride with the readers. And we just have to trust, you know, the vision. And I feel like Yulin Kuang, our writer/director, is so brilliant, and I know she’s going to do an amazing job,” Henry said. 

Other than that, she said she’s excited about the other actors they’re signing onto the project and they’re going to start shooting soon. Henry didn’t share any specific excitement or support for Schwarzenegger, or speak out to defend his casting to fans. 

(more…)